Thursday, November 19, 2026

When Is a Coat of Arms NOT a Coat of Arms?


Apparently, the answer to the question asked in the header is: "Whenever the organization using the arms-like logo says they don't have a coat of arms."

But first, some background.

Once again, I was sitting in my living room minding my own business and watching an old comedy special, "Gilda Live", written and performed by the late Gilda Radner. (Wow! Has it really been 37 years since she died? D*mn, I feel old!)

Anyway, one of the skits was of her newscaster character Roseanne Roseannadanna giving a speech to the new graduates of the Columbia University School of Journalism in New York City. And the podium from which she was speaking had on it a coat of arms.


That is to say, I thought it was a coat of arms, until I researched it further, and found out that apparently, I am mistaken, and that not everything that looks exactly like a coat of arms actually is a coat of arms.

Now, some history.

The "University Shield" (not "coat of arms") was first adopted by Columbia University in 1949, and looked like this:


The motto In lumine tuo videbimus lumen is Latin for "In Thy light shall we see light".

Later the University changed to a different "official" design that changes much of the original design, according to the university visual identity guide, and which makes it somewhat more "logo-like".


The website for the University tells us that "[t]he shield is technically not a 'coat of arms', and the University does not in fact have one."

It goes on to state that "[t]here are very few official uses of the shield these days except on bookstore merchandise, and the podium used for public events like Commencement." This last would account for its use (here, in an odd mix of both of the "official" versions) in a comedy skit which was supposed to be taking place on the campus of the University.

But to go back to our first question above: When is a coat of arms NOT a coat of arms?

I mean, if it looks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, what makes it not a duck?

Here, if it looks like a coat of arms, and acts like a coat of arms, what makes it not a coat of arms? The fact that the University says it isn't a coat of arms? And on what do they base that statement? Are they under the impression that all coats of arms must be granted by a duly-formed heraldic authority to be defined as a coat of arms? (If that is the case, it bodes poorly for the coat of arms, which I call a coat of arms, that I designed for myself and self-assumed. Should I refer to it now as the "Appleton shield" because it's not "really" a coat of arms?)

I don't have an answer to that original question. But it seems to me that if something looks like, and performs all of the functions of, a coat of arms, it is just nitpicking to claim that it is not a coat of arms, and decide that "the University does not in fact have one."

No comments:

Post a Comment