Thursday, November 19, 2026

When Is a Coat of Arms NOT a Coat of Arms?


Apparently, the answer to the question asked in the header is: "Whenever the organization using the arms-like logo says they don't have a coat of arms."

But first, some background.

Once again, I was sitting in my living room minding my own business and watching an old comedy special, "Gilda Live", written and performed by the late Gilda Radner. (Wow! Has it really been 37 years since she died? D*mn, I feel old!)

Anyway, one of the skits was of her newscaster character Roseanne Roseannadanna giving a speech to the new graduates of the Columbia University School of Journalism in New York City. And the podium from which she was speaking had on it a coat of arms.


That is to say, I thought it was a coat of arms, until I researched it further, and found out that apparently, I am mistaken, and that not everything that looks exactly like a coat of arms actually is a coat of arms.

Now, some history.

The "University Shield" (not "coat of arms") was first adopted by Columbia University in 1949, and looked like this:


The motto In lumine tuo videbimus lumen is Latin for "In Thy light shall we see light".

Later the University changed to a different "official" design that changes much of the original design, according to the university visual identity guide, and which makes it somewhat more "logo-like".


The website for the University tells us that "[t]he shield is technically not a 'coat of arms', and the University does not in fact have one."

It goes on to state that "[t]here are very few official uses of the shield these days except on bookstore merchandise, and the podium used for public events like Commencement." This last would account for its use (here, in an odd mix of both of the "official" versions) in a comedy skit which was supposed to be taking place on the campus of the University.

But to go back to our first question above: When is a coat of arms NOT a coat of arms?

I mean, if it looks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, what makes it not a duck?

Here, if it looks like a coat of arms, and acts like a coat of arms, what makes it not a coat of arms? The fact that the University says it isn't a coat of arms? And on what do they base that statement? Are they under the impression that all coats of arms must be granted by a duly-formed heraldic authority to be defined as a coat of arms? (If that is the case, it bodes poorly for the coat of arms, which I call a coat of arms, that I designed for myself and self-assumed. Should I refer to it now as the "Appleton shield" because it's not "really" a coat of arms?)

I don't have an answer to that original question. But it seems to me that if something looks like, and performs all of the functions of, a coat of arms, it is just nitpicking to claim that it is not a coat of arms, and decide that "the University does not in fact have one."

Monday, November 16, 2026

Fun With Stained Glass in Temple Church, Part 2


The other big heraldic window in Temple Church, London, that we're going to look at today has fewer coats of arms, but more heraldic symbols and flags that its companion window we looked at last time.

See if you can spot them. (Again, you can click on the image below to see the full-size photograph for easier viewing of all the details.)


At the top of the left-hand light we find the arms of King Henry I (Beauclerc). Gules two lions passant guardant in pale or. The image of the King is holding called Beauseant, for which see more below.


At the top of the right-hand light we have emblems of King Stephen. These emblems are A Latin cross or issuant from a crescent argent, between two (mullets of six points? also argent), in base a lion passant guardant or. The image of King Stephen is holding a banner of St. George, Argent a cross gules.


The arms usually attributed to King Stephen are Gules a sagittary or; so not what we see here.

At the bottom of the left-hand light we see an equestrian image of Geoffrey, son of Stephen (Galfridus filius Stephani), who served as the Master of the Knights Templar in England from roughly 1180 to 1185. During his tenure as "Minister of the soldiery of the Temple in England," he famously hosted the Patriarch Heraclius of Jerusalem at the New Temple in London for the historic consecration of the Temple Church.

And at the bottom of the right-hand light, we see an equestrian images of Aymeric de Saint Maur, the Master of the Knights Templar in England at the time of the First Barons' War and one of the most powerful men in the land. The arms on his shield are Argent two chevrons gules.


The flag or banner held by each of the Templar Masters in England (as well as King Henry I) is Beauseant (also spelled Baucent, Bausent, or Beausseant), the famous black-and-white war banner and battle cry of the Knights Templar during the Middle Ages: Per fess sable and argent.

According to the chronicler Jacques de Vitry, the black half represented terror to Christ's enemies, while the white half symbolized kindness and purity toward friends. The war cry was famously shouted in combat as part of the Templar cry: "À moi, beau sire! Beauséant à la rescousse!" ("To me, good sire! Beauséant to the rescue!").

The word beauséant comes from Old French (baucent or bauceant), originally used to describe a piebald (black-and-white patched) horse.*

Here again, we have a window containing a wealth of history, and heraldry, in its panes.  



* This reminds me of how the Greek god of the underworld, Hades, has his realm protected by a three-headed dog named Cerberus, which is the Latin form of the Greek Kerberos, which means “spotted”. Thus, the god of the underworld named his dog “Spot”.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Fun With Stained Glass in Temple Church, Part 1


Well, the book I ordered, Die Epitaphiern an der Frauenkirche zu München, has arrived, it's going to take me a few days to find the four heraldic memorials on the exterior of the cathedral in Munich (that Katie photographed for me) that I still have to identify in it, and then translate the text from the German, and then see if I can find blazons for the coats of arms on them (and if they are in Rietstap's Armorial Général, translating those from the French!).

In the meantime, though, I can't just leave you all wondering what's happened because you've had no blog posts from me in the meantime while I do all that, today and next time we are going to revisit the Temple Church in London and look at the arms in a couple of large stained glass windows there.

These windows are not those originally set in these openings, those having been pretty much destroyed during the Blitz and later V-1 and V-2 attacks on London during World War II.

For all that they are more recent replacements, though, they are each an impressive example of the work of the glaziers who created them. And they've got coats of arms in them, hence my sharing them with you here.

Today's window is this one here; see if you can find the five coats of arms and the one quasi-heraldic emblem in it. (As usual, you can click on the image below to see the full-size picture zoom in for the details of it.)


Did you see the arms?

In the left-hand light just below the top two figures, is the arms of the Knights Templars, for whom the Temple Church is named. They are blazoned Argent a cross paty gules.

Here's a close-up of those arms:


Opposite the Templar arms in the right-hand light is the arms of the Kingdom of Jerusalem, where the order had its beginnings. Those arms are blazoned: Argent a cross potent between four crosses couped or.

And here's a close-up of those arms:


Next, in the left-hand light below the central roundel showing St. Paul's Cathedral surrounded by flames (WWII again!) is a shield with the arms of the Honourable Society of the Inner Temple, Azure a Pegasus salient argent.

Matching it in the right-hand light is the arms of Honourable Society of the Middle Temple, Argent on a cross gules a Paschal lamb passant or maintaining a banner argent charged with a cross gules.

 And finally, in the center of the middle light just a little higher than the arms of the Inner and Middle Temples, we find the achievement of arms of the Worshipful Company of Glaziers, Argent two glazing-irons in saltire between four closing nails sable on a chief gules a demi-lion passant guardant or. The crest is A lion's head couped or between two wings expanded azure. And the supporters are Two naked boys each holding in his exterior hand a long torch inflamed proper.

So much for the heraldry. Did you find the emblem?

At the bottom of the right-hand light, we see an emblem of the Templars, two Knights Templar each bearing a shield of the arms of the Order on a single horse. This emblem is based on a tradition that they were so poor they rode two to a horse.


The emblem first appeared on the seal of Bertrand de Blanquefort, the order's sixth Grand Master, in 1158. It continued to be used by subsequent Grand Masters until the order's dissolution in 1312.

One common interpretation of the two knights on one horse is that it represents the early Templars' poverty. They were officially known as the "Poor Fellow-Soldiers of Christ and of the Temple of Solomon" and the symbol was seen as a reminder that they shared a single mount.

Another interpretation suggests that the symbol reflects the dual nature of the Templars, who were both monks and warriors. The single horse could represent the unification of these seemingly contrasting roles.

While the symbol might initially suggest poverty, it's important to note that the Templars' Rule did allow each knight to have three horses. So the emblem is more likely symbolic than literal.

There's an awful lot of history contained in this one window with three lights. I hope that you find it as awe-inspiring as I have!

Monday, November 9, 2026

Down the Heraldic Rabbit Hole


My friend Katie (who sent me all the pictures of heraldry from her river cruise in Europe that I've been posting here) saw a map at her work (it is on loan to the facility) that had a coat of arms on it and she wondered if perhaps I might be able to identify it for her. Her impression was that the charges on the shield looked like a bear's paw or bear's claws.

I said that I would certainly try, but naturally could make no firm representations about doing that with any certainty until I could actually see the coat of arms.

Well, she sent me some pictures.



And ... down the rabbit hole I went!

First: the map is made by Willem (1571-1638) and Johannes (1596-1673) Blaeu, father and son cartographers from Amsterdam.

Second: Sibenburgen. Siebenbürgen (note the extra "e", as well as the umlaut) is the German name for Transylvania, now a part of the country of Romania. It translates to "Seven Fortresses" or "Seven Towns", the seven major medieval walled cities built and settled by Transylvanian Saxons (German colonists who arrived in the region starting in the 12th century):

1. Brașov (Kronstadt)
2. Sibiu (Hermannstadt)
3. Cluj-Napoca (Klausenburg)
4. Sighișoara (Schässburg)
5. Mediaș (Mediasch)
6. Sebeș (Mühlbach)
7. Bistrița (Bistritz)

And, indeed, the modern arms of the region of Transylvania include on them seven red towers representing the seven towns. Which I think is a really nice nod to the history of the area. Just sayin'.

With all that now as background information, neither the arms of Transylvania nor the arms of any of the seven towns or of the regions in which they are located come even close to matching the arms on the map.

More research into the arms of the principality of Transylvania and its rulers led me to this conclusion: the arms on the map appear to be at least based on, if they are not meant entirely to represent, the arms of the Báthory princes of Transylvania: Stephen Báthory, 1576–1586, who was Voivode (military governor, warlord, or regional ruler) of Transylvania 1571–1576; Sigismund Báthory, 1586–1598, abdicated 1599; and Andrew Báthory, 1599.

The Báthory arms are Gules three wolves’ teeth issuant from (usually sinister, but sometimes from dexter, as on the map) argent.

The arms on the map are Azure three wolves’ teeth issuant from dexter argent, and the shield is surmounted by a princely cap. All of the coloring on the map is done by hand, so there is lots of room for miscoloration of the arms. Or perhaps someone was trying differentiate the arms of the province (Transylvania) from the arms of its prince (Báthory). Or they didn’t really know what the color of the field should be, and just made it what they wanted. This map was done back in the early 17th Century, after all!

And while the charges on the shield do look a bit like bear’s claws, they are much closer to the German heraldic charge of wolves’ teeth. The image immediately below is of the Báthory arms from a 1595 portrait of Zsigmond [Sigismund] Báthori, surrounded by the emblem of the Order of the Dragon.* You can clearly see the similarity.


Here, too, the field is hatched for heraldic red (gules), rather than the heraldic blue (azure) that it is on the map.

And thus I passed a pleasant afternoon, falling down the rabbit hole of identifying a coat of arms on a 400-year-old map temporarily adorning the wall of a presidential library and museum in Arkansas, having no idea where the trail would end up taking me when I first began it.




* The Order of the Dragon (Societas Draconistarum) was a monarchical chivalric order founded in 1408 by King Sigismund of Luxembourg (later Holy Roman Emperor) and his queen, Barbara of Cilli. It was created to defend Christian Europe -- particularly Hungary and the Balkans -- against the expanding Ottoman Empire and to secure political loyalty among the aristocracy.

Vlad II Dracul was a prince of Wallachia who joined the order in 1431; his membership earned him the surname Dracul ("the Dragon"). His son, Vlad III (Vlad Țepeș, or in English, Vlad the Impaler), became known as Dracula ("son of the dragon"), whose brutal reputation later inspired Bram Stoker's vampire novel, which in turn inspired a slew of horror movies.

And it is just this sort of history that makes researching heraldry not only interesting, but so much fun!

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Well, That Was Weird!


I am learning to live in this new age of so-called "smart" appliances this and "artificial intelligence" that, though I still find it slightly creepy when my doorbell sends me a text or an email to let me know that its battery is low and that I need to replace it.

And I occasionally have people email me with comments or questions about something I have posted here on this blog, or simply because they have an heraldic question that they think I might be able to answer or at least give them some insight into.

What I was not prepared for a couple of weeks ago was to have both of those things in the first two paragraphs to overlap.

In a first (to me, at least!), I had an A.I. agent send me an email asking a question about heraldry and coats of arms (though it did tend to call them "marks").

It gave me just a little background to lead up to the question it wanted answered, which was essentially whether any "returns" based on the 1417 writ by King Henry V of England regarding the bearing of coats of arms (by ancestral right or by grant) still survive, or whether the first English "register" of arms were the Heralds' Visitations of the Tudor era.

In my response, I suggested that the College of Arms in London would probably give it the most comprehensive answer to the first half of its qusetion, whether any/all of the Henry V returns still exist.

For the second half of its question, regarding the Visitations, I noted the occasional rolls of arms of King Henry III and King Edward I, while comparatively limited in scope (I mean, they are called "occasional rolls" because they were created upon some "occasion" like a battle), could probably be considered earlier "registers" of coats of arms.

But is it weird that I find myself somewhat unsettled by receiving an inquiry about heraldry from something that tells me plainly that "I will say plainly what I am. I am an AI agent ...." Because, frankly, I am just not sure how I feel about that.

Monday, November 2, 2026

Once You Start Looking For It ...


... you will begin to find heraldry everywhere!

Once again, I have done it sitting in my living room on my own couch while not even thinking about heraldry at all.

In the little village of Castil de Campos, in the municipal territory of Priego de Córdoba, itself in the southeasternmost end of the province of Córdoba, Spain, is the Mesón Restaurante Balcón de Cheva (Cheva’s Balcony Restaurant and Inn). The restaurant is a highly regarded local fixture in the small town. 

Indeed, given that the population of the village is only about 700 people, it would be hard-pressed to not be a local fixture!

Anyway, there I was, watching (once again) House Hunters International on HGTV, and this couple was looking for a home in Castil de Campos, Spain, and some of the filming was done just outside the restaurant, and showed its sign:



You will quickly note, as I did, the two shields on this sign.

On the left (and ignoring the gold edging around both these shields, which appears to be merely a baroque scroll-like framing for the shield), we see: Vert a cross or. On the ribbon beneath the shield: Oníeva.

And on the right: Sable a lion rampant crowned maintaining a mullet [of five points] or. On the ribbon beneath the shield: Luque.

The helmet above the shields with its decorative blue and white "mantling" and "crest" is pretty clearly just artistic and does not belong to either of the coats of arms.  

Neither of these shields is of the arms of the village of Castil de Campos, the municipal territory of Priego de Córdoba, the province of Córdoba, the Kingdom of Spain, or any other civic arms from the area.

I suspect they are arms of two families, whether granted or assumed, presumably those of the proprietors or owners of the restaurant.

It continues to surprise me sometimes, that I can just be sitting here in my living room and have heraldry just pop up in front of me like that!